Building a shareable email content strategy for marketing means understanding what makes emails get forwarded — the highest compliment your email marketing system can earn. The highest compliment anyone can pay your email marketing system is not a five-star review, not a testimonial, not even a purchase. It is a forward. A forwarded email means someone thought it was good enough to put their own reputation behind by sharing it with someone they know.
Why people forward things
Three drivers consistently motivate sharing. First: social currency — people share things that make them look smart, informed, or generous to the recipient. Second: genuine utility — sharing something the recipient will actually use. Third: surprise — forwarding something because they could not believe how good it was and did not want the recipient to miss it. Emails designed with all three in mind get forwarded. Emails designed to sell usually do not.
What forwarded emails have in common
A genuinely surprising insight
Not a tip your subscriber could Google. Something that challenges an assumption they held. Something that makes them stop and think ‘I never thought about it that way.’ The bar for genuinely surprising someone is higher than most email marketers set it. You have to actually know something specific — from years of doing the work, making mistakes, seeing edge cases. Earned expertise is the thing that generates real surprise.
Specificity that feels almost too narrow
The paradox of email content: the more specific you get, the more universally the content resonates. An email about ‘how to improve your email marketing’ gets skimmed. An email about ‘the exact reason your abandoned cart email is not recovering sales even though it looks fine’ gets read and forwarded. Specificity signals depth. People forward depth, not breadth.
A specific invitation to share at the end
Adding a forward invitation at the end of qualifying emails increases forwards by 30 to 40 percent. But it must be specific: not ‘share this with anyone who might find it useful’ — that is too vague to motivate action. ‘If you know someone who runs a Shopify store and is frustrated that email is not working, forward this to them’ — that makes the forwarding decision easy. The recipient immediately thinks of one or two specific people.
Writing Emails People Love is a guide to the five psychology principles that turn your emails from inbox noise into something subscribers actually look forward to — $17 at signifystudio.com/library.
The forward as a list growth strategy
A forwarded email brings in a warm lead — someone who received a recommendation from a person they trust, who has already read something you wrote and found it valuable. who starts their relationship with you already predisposed to engage. Warm leads convert at dramatically higher rates than cold leads, have higher lifetime values, and refer more people themselves. If 2 percent of your 500 subscribers forward one email per month and half of those recipients subscribe, you are adding 5 new warm subscribers per month with no ad spend. It compounds.
Need more tools and frameworks? Browse everything at signifystudio.com/library.
Is Your Email Marketing System Actually Working?
Most DTC brands are leaving $4,000 to $9,000 in monthly email revenue on the table. Find out exactly where your Klaviyo program stands — free, in minutes.
